Okay, grab this: sign up for Koinly's free tier first thing. Import your wallets, run a preview report, and boom-you see your gains or losses without spending a dime. Why? 'Cause it handles 400+ exchanges outta the box, way more than most. I did this last year with my messy Binance and Coinbase history, saved hours of manual CSV bullshit. Sound familiar? If you're drowning in trades, this hack gets you 80% there instantly.
Now, taxes in 2026? They're no joke. IRS is sniffing around DeFi swaps and NFT flips harder than ever. But don't sweat it-these tools like Koinly and CoinLedger basically do the math for you. Koinly leads 'cause it's got broader reach, killer reconciliation to catch errors, and covers 100+ countries. CoinLedger's solid too, especially if you're US based and TurboTax obsessed. In my experience, pick based on your trade volume. Low? Either works. High? Koinly's cheaper long term.
Look, I usually start with Koinly. Launched back in 2018, it's grown into this beast that auto imports from Coinbase, Binance, Kraken-you name it. 400+ connections. That's huge if you've got wallets scattered everywhere.
The thing is, it nails price tracking at the exact transaction moment. No fuzzy estimates. Feeds right into your capital gains calc using FIFO, LIFO, HIFO, even weird ones like Spec ID or Average Cost Basis. Why does this matter? Mismatched cost basis = audit nightmare. Koinly's double entry ledger and balance checks spot that shit early.
Pro tip: if imports glitch on niche DEXes, upload CSV. Koinly parses it clean. Happened to me with a Solana swap-gas fee was ~0.000005 SOL, it caught it perfect. No overpaying taxes.
Honestly, CoinLedger's interface feels snappier for newbies. Started as CryptoTrader.Tax, rebranded 2022. Great for US, UK, Aus, Canada-16 countries total. But if you're global, it lags Koinly.
Users gripe sometimes about manual fixes for gifts or mislabels. Fix? Their live chat's quick. I chatted once, dude fixed my staking reward tag in 5 mins.
Basically same as Koinly.
What's next? Test both free. CoinLedger shines if you've got tons of tiny assets; Koinly if you're DeFi heavy with lending or NFTs.
| Koinly | CoinLedger | |
|---|---|---|
| Exchanges/Wallets | 400+ | 55+ |
| Countries | 100+ | 16 |
| Assets | 17k | 20k+ |
| Cost Methods | FIFO/LIFO/HIFO + ACB, Spec ID | FIFO/LIFO/HIFO |
| Free Tier | Preview reports | Portfolio + gains preview |
| Plans (100 txns) | $49 | $49 |
| 3k txns | $179 (Trader) | $199 (Unlimited) |
| 10k+ txns | $279 | Extra fees |
| TurboTax? | Yes | Yes (stronger) |
| DeFi/NFT | Auto tags most | Good, but manual sometimes |
See? For under 1k trades, identical cost. Over that, Koinly pulls ahead-especially with 30% off links floating around. High volume? Koinly's $279 handles 10k+, no extras.
Okay, real talk. Imports fail? Check API permissions-exchanges like Binance need "read only" enabled. Don't grant trades/withdraws.
Missing on chain fees? CoinLedger's better here, pulls ETH gas automatically. Koinly might need manual add-~0.0005 ETH for a swap, easy tag.
NFT sales? Both support, but verify. Sold a Bored Ape? Tag as "NFT sale," cost basis from mint (~0.01 ETH gas).
Staking rewards? Income, not capital gain. Koinly auto detects most; CoinLedger too, but double check Lido or Rocket Pool.
In my experience, always run balance check. Koinly's got auto recon-flags if your wallet end balance don't match. Saved my ass once with a forgotten airdrop.
Tax loss harvesting? Both show opportunities. Sell losers to offset gains-Koinly's tool ranks 'em by savings potential.
Both free to start. Pay per tax year, based on txns.
Koinly: Newbie $49 (100 txns), Hodler $99 (1k), Trader $179 (3k), Unlimited ish $279 (10k+). Crypto payments? Yeah, BTC/ETH/USDC. Cool perk.
CoinLedger: Hobbyist $49 (100), Investor $99 (1k), Unlimited $199 (3k)-but over 3k? Extra bucks. No crypto pay.
Pretty much even for casuals. Power trader? Koinly wins. I went Trader plan, imported 2.5k txns from Solana farms, cost me $179 after discount. Worth every penny.
You're farming yield on Uniswap V3? Koinly tags liquidity adds/withdraws auto. Fees? Tiny, like 0.3% pool fee minus ~10 gwei gas.
Margin trades? Koinly handles Kraken full; others manual. Derivatives? Spotty on both-CSV those.
NFT dashboard in Koinly? Fire. Tracks floor prices, gains from flips. CoinLedger's okay, but less depth.
Portfolio tracking: Both live. CoinLedger shows ROI per asset; Koinly adds maturity dates for short/long term gains.
Security? Both encrypt, 2FA. Koinly GDPR/SOC2 compliant. No hacks reported.
If US TurboTax user with simple trades-CoinLedger. Intuitive, fast exports.
Global, high volume, DeFi/NFT mess? Koinly. More integrations, better error proofing, cheaper scales.
But try free first. Import same wallet to both. See what clicks. I flipped between 'em twice before sticking Koinly.
One last thing: rules change yearly. These nail FIFO etc. but chat a tax pro for your spot. Especially if business or massive gains.